Opera Praktikos’ earliest lessons in accessibility came from a rather unlikely place: the bathroom.
During the disability-affirmative opera company’s first opera, co-founder and executive producer Marianna Mott Newirth found herself responsible for renting a wheelchair-accessible portable toilet. “The glitz and glamour of opera,” she jokingly called it. During the planning of a later production, Newirth had found a seemingly ideal venue, affordable and beautiful. The bathrooms, however, were not accessible, including for Opera Praktikos’ (OPrak) co-founder and artistic director Greg Moomjy, who uses a wheelchair.
“We had a real couple of hours discussion, and it was not an easy one, about what is more important,” Newirth said. “That there be bathrooms that everybody can use, or that we have the ideal venue except that it didn’t have accessible bathrooms?” In the end, they chose accessibility.
“That really was a turning point for our company because the priority was accessible bathrooms…you can’t call yourself a disability-affirmative opera company and then be in a venue that only people who are fully ambulatory can use the bathroom,” she added.
OPrak, formed in 2022 through the collaboration of Newirth and Moomjy, is what happens when disability no longer takes a back seat in the arts but becomes a creative force.
The New York-based opera company describes its work as interabled, bringing artists of various backgrounds and lived experiences to opera. Newirth and Moomjy’s partnership after years of working together has become symbiotic. “Greg and I, we’re kindred spirits. We understand each other,” Newirth said. “We have a deep respect and love for one another.” She also adds how neither would be able to do this without the other. “It’s really an exquisite partnership, and we call each other partner in opera. He is my partner in opera in many, many, many ways,” she said.
On Nov. 18 as part of the makemake festival at National Sawdust in Brooklyn, OPrak will showcase this with an orchestral concert version of their reimagining of Bellini and Romani’s nearly 200-year-old opera La Sonnambula (The Sleepwalker).
Moomjy, who has cerebral palsy and has written for years about the intersection of disability and opera, was able to see something in La Sonnambula that most might overlook. “La Sonnambula is seen as a cute fable in the opera world, but actually our performance is more than this,” Moomjy wrote in a message discussing the company’s June workshop. “It is an important work that highlights similarities in the disabled community.”
OPrak co-founders Gregory Moomjy and Marianna Mott Newirth. Photo courtesy: Opera Praktikos.
OPrak has moved Lisa, a minor character in the original opera, closer to the center of the story and made her Deaf. “Lisa isn’t just Deaf for the novelty of it,” Moomjy notes. The company created a history for Lisa and her deafness rather than making the change simply for the sake of adding a disabled character. “It wasn’t random,” Newirth adds. “We give actual reason for why the character of Lisa is Deaf and what are the ramifications of what caused her deafness that is still impacting the community. This is our story.”
To make their story come to life, the company first had to translate the original Italian opera into English as well as American Sign Language (ASL) gloss, a process, Newirth said, that requires collaboration between hearing and Deaf members of their creative team. “ASL does not actually translate word for word,” Newirth said. “ASL relies a great deal on metaphor.” In short, this is no small task. “We’re learning what new levels of prioritization really require, and we’re learning this with the Deaf community now,” she said. “We’re learning what we assume the Deaf community wants and the Deaf community is like, ‘No, we don’t really want that.’ And it’s like, ‘Oh, okay.’”
OPrak hopes to open doors for disability-affirmative opera in the future and start a dialogue about what interable opera looks like with accessibility at the core.
“We are tackling the topic of ableism but not from a ‘you shouldn’t be ableist,’ I mean we’re all ableist…it’s just undistinguished largely in our society and our goal is to distinguish it in this opera for the audience to begin to think ‘oh maybe I have an ableist reaction to this’,” Newirth said. “We’re not giving a morality lesson here, what we’re doing is explaining through our particular vehicle of opera, demonstrating what happens when a person who is Deaf is living in a community with non-Deaf people.”
Opera Praktikos’ reimagining of La Sonnambula will continue this fall before a fully staged performance next year. They hope this will be a way to make audiences think more critically about ableism and how disabled people are understood within their communities.
“The town is sleepwalking itself,” Moomjy comments. “We’re all sort of sleepwalking,” Newirth adds. “Sleepwalking our way through ableism.”
Shayla Montalvo is a reporter with The SBU Media Group, part of Stony Brook University’s School of Communication and Journalism’s Working Newsroom program for students and local media.