October 29, 2002 was a day of freedom that people with disabilities had been waiting a long time for: individuals in need of adaptations to vote independently had gained protections for improved voting accessibility through the Help Americans Vote Act (HAVA).
HAVA was established and signed by then-President George W. Bush, ensuring equal opportunity for all American citizens, regardless of limitations, to exercise their civil right to vote. This meant people with disabilities could vote privately and independently.
One person who greatly benefited from HAVA is Ms. Marilyn Tucci of Shirley, NY.
Tucci is legally blind and when the veteran voter found out that inaccessibility would no longer stop her from voting without assistance, her reaction was one of great enthusiasm.
“Oh my God, now I can vote independently…I used to have somebody go in (the polling site) with me to pull a curtain and a lever.” Now Tucci is able to use a Ballot Marking Device to cast her vote on her own.
However, since the inception of accessible voting machines, operating them has not always been a smooth process. The (sometimes) lack of ease of operation results in unjust treatment toward people with disabilities, making it necessary for them to rely on others for assistance.
Tucci remembers quite a few times that there were problems with the machines. Instead of being able to vote in less than 15 minutes, she would often be there for hours, listening to excuses from staff as to why the machines weren’t working. As a result, she needed someone to physically help her with her vote.
Then, in the 2020 federal election, Tucci tried to cast her vote at Brookhaven Town Hall; she again had issues with the machines and the staff.
After an unsuccessful attempt to vote using the Dominion ImageCast®, which uses the Ballot Marking Device (BMD) to make the voting process accessible, she was informed of her right to file a HAVA Complaint.
Armed with knowledge from American Disabled for Attendant Programs Today (ADAPT), Tucci filed a complaint under HAVA with the New York State Board of Elections (SBOE) on December 4, 2020. The complaint alleges “certain conduct that constitutes violations of Title III of the Help America Vote Act of 2002.”
Tucci recounts, “I’ve never done anything like that before. I just felt like my right to privacy and independence [was] taken away. And two people had to help me vote, which I kind of resented because I didn’t have anybody with me. So, I was really annoyed by that.” She continues, “So, I did a HAVA complaint. And when we had the hearing, they agreed with everything I said.”
Tucci had no trouble voting in the 2021 and 2022 elections. She said, “I think everything went smooth[ly] with those two years of voting after I filed that HAVA Complaint. And I was so happy because I’m in and out of there in 10-12 minutes. No problems.”
Then in November 2023, Tucci expected to vote independently at an early voting poll site. She experienced a new level of frustration: the ballot marking device (BMD) was not properly placed for privacy; the staff was not adherent to HAVA.
“I signed in (at the polling place) and this woman approached me and I said, ‘I’d like to use the accessible voting machine, please.’ And she said okay. She showed me where it was… I put my hand on it. And then I said, could you please turn the machine around?”
Ms. Tucci points out that’s one thing she should not have to broach. “It should be automatic that one machine is facing the wall.” Tucci had to ask a poll worker three times to turn the machine around. Additionally, she needed headphones to use according to her, should have been automatically provided, but weren’t. Tucci had to request them from a poll worker. “I asked her for the paper that goes over the earphones for cleanliness,” Tucci recalled, but the poll worker said “we will just throw them away.”
Following the directions on the BMD, Tucci completed the full process of selecting and submitting her votes. However, a poll worker notified her that the machine did not retain the entries, but instead produced a blank ballot.
The poll worker did not offer to troubleshoot the machine. When Tucci asked if she could use one of the other two machines, she was told that the machines were scanners, not accessible voting machines.
The poll workers suggested she take two staff members into the poll booth with her. Tucci declined the offer, as it would violate her privacy.
She instead asked her friend Elysia who had accompanied her to help. Tucci said, “If I was going to let anybody vote for me, I would ask my friend… Why should a Democrat or a Republican know who I’m voting for?” Tucci’s voting companion later wrote a letter to the Board of Electors defending Tucci’s case.
In February 2024, Tucci filed another Complaint under HAVA, detailing her November 2023 voting troubles. A hearing was held in April 2024, and in early June 2024, the SBOE found that her experiences had indeed violated HAVA and must be remedied in the future with proper training for poll workers.
Tucci’s mixed bag of experiences is reflected more broadly in a new report, “Voting Experiences Since HAVA: Perspectives of People with Disabilities Report to the U.S. Election Assistance Commission,” which shows that HAVA has ultimately brought about progress.
Overall, polling places are becoming more physically accessible. Parking spaces and ramps have been more readily available, the availability of accessible voting machines has increased, and the needs of voters have been met with mail in-voting and accessible ballot delivery and return. Mail-in voting increased the number of disabled persons who chose to vote; however, this did not change the problem of voting independently for all.
As the report explains, “Overall, both the survey and focus group data indicates that HAVA has made a significant difference in the voting experiences of many people with disabilities. At the same time, challenges remain, particularly for those with vision, cognitive, and invisible disabilities such as anxiety.”
The accomplishments of HAVA are noteworthy. With that said, as the report shows, “further efforts should be made to address both long-standing challenges such as polling place accessibility, and recent difficulties such as health and safety concerns, that are faced by people with disabilities.”